mnmlist: downsides of minimalism

It’s true that I might too often make minimalism seem like it’s all roses, all upside. But there is a downside to everything, including minimalism.

In order to better prepare you, my lovely and good-hearted reader, for minimalism, it’s my duty to point out some of the downsides. Consider this post my due diligence.

Some downsides to minimalism:

  • You get to know Craigslist, Goodwill and other charities all too well as you clean out your clutter.
  • You have to figure out other things to do with yourself besides shopping and browsing shopping sites.
  • If you travel lightly for a few weeks with only a small carry-on, customs officers might get suspicious — who travels with almost nothing, besides maybe a terrorist? My friends Corbett Barr and his wife Jessie recently had this experience going into Europe with a small bag each — officials didn’t believe they were really traveling for three weeks without luggage.
  • People will tease you about which of your two shirts you’re wearing today. I don’t mind this — there are worse things to be teased about.
  • If you are a well known minimalist and happen to shop at the Gap or the Apple store, you worry that people will see you and judge you for hypocrisy.
  • If you give up your cable TV, you have to find other things to do. I like to read or exercise. Also, you aren’t aware of non-Internet pop culture — I had to Google Jwow recently (didn’t know who she was) and was shocked at how much I’ve apparently been missing.
  • Family will harass you about not buying gifts. They will live. So will you.
  • You don’t get as good a workout walking around with a light bag instead of one laden with lots of stuff. I put weight plates in my backpack if I want to compensate for this.
  • People online will accuse you of being “trendy” because you’re a minimalist. People who aren’t online as much will wonder what the hell a minimalist is.
  • Your one pair of jeans will go from being dark and dressy to faded, frayed, and more welcome in an Occupy camp than in nice restaurants.
  • When family comes to visit, you’ll be confused as to why they have so much stuff with them, even if they’re just there to visit for a few hours.
  • When you go to other people’s houses, you might start mentally fantasizing about getting rid of their stuff for them.
  • People will ask you, almost non-stop, how you can be a minimalist with so many kids. If you don’t have any kids, they’ll roll your eyes and say, “Of course you’re a minimalist — you’re a bachelor!”
  • People will always, always try to point out the hypocrisy of being a minimalist and something else about you — your articles are too long to be a minimalist! You have 25 books — that’s not minimalist! Etc.
  • Others might feel threatened by you, because your minimalism will be seen as a criticism of their lifestyle. They will live.
  • You will get weird looks when you turn down free “schwag” at sporting events, conferences, parties. Who doesn’t want a bunch of free promotional junk?
  • People will give you pitying looks when they see you have a simple dumb phone, and can’t play Angry Birds or use Instagram on the train like they can.
  • If you don’t have a car, people will think you’re poor, even if you are wealthier for not having the car. And healthier, and time rich.


all posts



2011
December
28Kindle & iPad are marketing devices
14Finding yourself in spareness
November
30buckshot vs. rifle approaches
23downsides of minimalism
October
28minimalist protest
20Featurecreep & grandparents
4You don’t need the new iPhone
August
30on wanting stuff
23avoid new gear
11a minimalist in NYC
1the minimalism of tea
July
20i’m not playing that game
4paring ideas
June
21the just in case syndrome
3can you live without?
May
25walking ads
5the most minimal blog
March
23city vs. country minimalism
19minimalism’s critics
1spartan pizza napoletana
January
27I am not a brewer
20minimalism vs. fear


2010
December
20localization
8petite-productivity
November
25live more, need less
18free of advertising
11fewer bills
6paring down
October
30minimalism vs. the corporation
21the zen of limits
September
2510 essentials
15using notational velocity
7addition by subtraction
August
31letting go of fake needs
21undistracted reading
14minimalism is just the start
July
25a fresh start
18moving to a new home
June
10‘I could never give up’
1minimalism isn’t just for the affluent
May
26the beauty of a digital vacation
18the beauty of the ellipsis
11we are not consumers
6on economy
April
29manufacturing content
23society, reimagined: how to make it reality
21society, reimagined
16you need less than you think
14the only thing you can change
9the price of convenience
5possessions != security
5why i won’t be buying an ipad
March
30on finding contentedness
25the joy of walking
18minimalist backup
18minimalist fun
15empower people to create
10the creativity of constraints
9why i deleted 1,000 Facebook friends
5stop making it complicated
3wash your bowl
February
26the minimalism of veganism
22letting go of desires
15cherished mementos
8clear distractions
7mnmlist in 50 words
3minimalism in steps
January
28minimalist eating
18minimalist books


2009
December
22reduce your footprint
8eating less to be lighter
2slowness isn't comprehension
1slow, effective reading
November
22what twitter needs to add next
17unfriending
10learn to love less
4simplicity is the path
3The sweet science of less mail
October
30the 400-word promise
30the beauty of small
27on owning nothing
22the lust for new things
20avoid new stuff
16beat advertising
12unautomate: do it by hand
7the art of brief emails
4minimalism, the quick method
1the true cost of stuff
September
29break free from goals
22minimalist mac setup
21store everything in text files
18clutter is procrastination
16buying is not the solution
14revolt: get free from the tyranny of being current
11how to be less busy in a busy busy world
10minimalist FAQs
9carry less, or pockets like air
85 simple steps to declutter your closet
7win over non-minimalists
7how to let go of possessions
7getting to minimal: all the info you need to track
6minimalism is the end of organizing
6if you had to move, what would you take?
6step lightly upon this world
6consumerism vs. minimalism
6why less stuff is better
6rethinking necessities
6uncopyright and the minimalist mindset
5my minimalist desktop
4what is mnmlist.com?

subscribe